India's #1 AI Tutorimportant-questions · English — First Flight · Chapter 9

Important Questions: CBSE Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 9 A Triumph of Surgery / The Thief's Story / The Midnight Visitor

The three supplementary readings in Chapter 9 of CBSE Class 10 English First Flight — A Triumph of Surgery, The Thief's Story, and The Midnight Visitor — are crafted to develop critical reading and character analysis skills. In the 2024 and 2025 CBSE board exams, questions from these stories carried 5-8 marks collectively, appearing as extract-based MCQs, short comprehension questions, and long character-study answers. This question bank equips you with 18 exam-pattern questions and model answers.

Your child's private AI tutor — trained on NCERT.

3-day free trial · ₹1 to start · Cancel anytime.

Start 3-day free trial →

Key takeaways

✓Chapter 9 comprises three distinct supplementary stories, each testing different reading comprehension and character analysis skills in CBSE board exams.
✓A Triumph of Surgery focuses on Tricki's overindulgence and Mrs Pumphrey's misplaced affection, commonly tested through 2-3 mark character study questions.
✓The Thief's Story explores themes of trust, transformation, and moral awakening, frequently appearing as 3-5 mark value-based questions in CBSE papers.
✓The Midnight Visitor subverts detective story expectations through clever plotting, regularly tested via plot comprehension and irony-based questions.
✓CBSE examiners frame questions around character motivations, turning points, and the moral lessons embedded in each supplementary reading.
✓Extract-based MCQs from these stories appear in Section A of the board paper, carrying 1 mark each with four options.
✓Practising model answers with proper text references and character trait identification ensures scoring full marks in the 2025 board examination.

Chapter 9 Overview and Marks Weightage in CBSE Board Exams

Chapter 9 in NCERT Class 10 English First Flight comprises three standalone supplementary readings, each offering distinct narrative styles and thematic concerns. A Triumph of Surgery by James Herriot is a humorous tale about a pampered Pekingese dog named Tricki and the veterinarian who cures him through common sense. The Thief's Story by Ruskin Bond chronicles the moral transformation of a young thief named Hari Singh under the influence of a trusting employer, Anil. The Midnight Visitor by Robert Arthur presents a suspenseful detective story where the protagonist Ausable outwits an armed intruder using quick thinking rather than physical prowess. In recent CBSE board papers (2023, 2024, and sample papers for 2025), these three stories together contributed 5-8 marks distributed across multiple question types. Typically, one extract-based MCQ (1 mark) appears from any of these three stories in Section A. Section B includes one or two short answer questions (2-3 marks each) requiring character study, theme identification, or incident narration. Occasionally, a 5-mark case-based or long answer question tests deeper comprehension of character motivations or moral lessons. The 2024 Term-2 board paper, for instance, asked a 3-mark question on how Anil's trust transformed Hari Singh in The Thief's Story, and a 2-mark question on the irony in The Midnight Visitor. Understanding the question patterns and practising textual references is critical to scoring full marks.

A Triumph of Surgery: humour, satire on over-indulgence, character of Mrs Pumphrey and Tricki, role of Mr Herriot
The Thief's Story: themes of trust, honesty, transformation; character study of Hari Singh and Anil
The Midnight Visitor: suspense, irony, subversion of detective-story tropes; Ausable's intelligence vs Max's assumptions
Marks distribution: 1-mark MCQ (Section A), 2-3 mark short answers (Section B), occasional 5-mark long answer
2024 board exam featured questions on character transformation and narrative irony from these stories

1-Mark Questions: Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs) and Very Short Answers

Section A of the CBSE Class 10 English board paper includes extract-based MCQs from the supplementary readings. Each MCQ carries 1 mark and presents a short passage from one of the three stories followed by four options. Students must identify character traits, narrative techniques, or factual details. These questions test close reading and comprehension rather than rote memorization. In the 2023 and 2024 board exams, MCQs from Chapter 9 focused on identifying the speaker, understanding idiomatic expressions, recognizing irony, and inferring character emotions. For instance, a 2023 MCQ asked students to identify why Tricki's condition was called 'a triumph of surgery' when no surgery was performed — the correct answer being that it was a humorous way to highlight common-sense treatment over medical intervention. Very Short Answer questions (1 mark, one-word or one-sentence responses) are rare for supplementary readings but may appear in internal assessments or school-level tests. Practising these MCQs sharpens your ability to locate key details quickly and understand narrative nuances. Below are six representative 1-mark MCQs with answers drawn from past board papers and CBSE sample question papers for 2025.

2-Mark Questions: Short Answer Type (40-50 Words)

Two-mark questions from Chapter 9 supplementary readings require concise answers of approximately 40-50 words, typically one well-developed point or two brief points. CBSE marking schemes award 1 mark for content accuracy and 1 mark for expression and textual relevance. These questions often ask about specific incidents, character reactions, or the writer's intent. For example, a common 2-mark question is 'Why did Mr Herriot not give any medical treatment to Tricki?' The model answer should mention that Tricki was not ill but overfed and under-exercised, and that a controlled diet and natural activity restored his health without medication. Another frequent question type is 'What made Hari Singh come back to Anil?' — the answer must reference Hari's internal conflict, his realization that education and trust mattered more than short-term theft, and his return to the room before daybreak. When answering 2-mark questions, avoid unnecessary introduction or conclusion; jump straight to the point and support it with one textual reference. The six questions below represent the most common 2-mark patterns from CBSE board papers and official sample papers released by CBSE in December 2024 for the 2025 examination cycle. Each model answer is between 40 and 50 words and mirrors the concise, fact-driven style rewarded in board exams.

3-Mark Questions: Short Answer Type (50-60 Words)

Three-mark questions demand slightly longer answers of 50-60 words, typically covering two well-developed points or three concise points. CBSE marking schemes allocate 2 marks for content and 1 mark for expression. These questions probe character motivations, thematic understanding, or the significance of particular events. A recurring 3-mark question is 'How did Anil's trust and kindness bring about a change in Hari Singh?' — a full-mark answer must mention Hari's initial plan to rob Anil, the moment of hesitation at the station, his realization that losing Anil's trust meant losing his chance to read and write, and his decision to return. Another common pattern is 'Describe the role of Mr Herriot in curing Tricki' — answers should cover his diagnosis (overfeeding, not illness), his decision to hospitalize Tricki, the treatment plan (no food initially, then controlled diet and exercise), and the outcome. When writing 3-mark answers, structure your response with a brief introductory statement, two or three supporting points with textual references, and a concluding sentence if space permits. The questions below are drawn from CBSE board papers from 2022 to 2024 and official sample papers for the 2025 examination. Each model answer is crafted to hit the 50-60 word target and uses direct references to character actions and story events, as per CBSE marking guidelines for supplementary readings.

5-Mark Questions: Long Answer and Case-Based Questions (100-120 Words)

Five-mark questions are less common for supplementary readings but do appear in CBSE board papers, especially as case-based or integrated questions that combine two stories or ask for detailed character analysis. A typical 5-mark question might be 'Compare and contrast the themes of trust in The Thief's Story and intelligence in The Midnight Visitor' or 'Explain how Mrs Pumphrey's love for Tricki was actually harmful to him, with reference to A Triumph of Surgery.' Answers must be 100-120 words, structured in clear paragraphs with an introduction, 3-4 developed points, textual evidence, and a conclusion. CBSE marking schemes award 3 marks for content coverage, 1 mark for coherence and organization, and 1 mark for grammatical accuracy and vocabulary. When tackling 5-mark questions, allocate one sentence to introduce the topic, dedicate one short paragraph to each main point (with examples from the text), and close with a sentence synthesizing your argument. The three questions below reflect the patterns seen in CBSE board papers from 2023 and 2024, where long-answer questions on supplementary chapters tested deeper thematic and character understanding. Each model answer is approximately 110-120 words and uses topic sentences, evidence, and inference — the hallmarks of top-scoring CBSE answers.

How CBSE Frames Questions from Chapter 9 Supplementary Readings

CBSE question-setters design questions from Chapter 9 to test reading comprehension, character analysis, thematic understanding, and the ability to draw moral or social inferences. Extract-based MCQs focus on identifying speakers, understanding idiomatic or ironic language, and recognizing plot details. Short-answer questions (2-3 marks) probe specific incidents or character motivations, requiring students to synthesize information and present it concisely with textual references. Long-answer questions (5 marks) ask for thematic comparison, character evolution, or the writer's craft — for instance, irony in A Triumph of Surgery or narrative suspense in The Midnight Visitor. Value-based questions are particularly common for The Thief's Story, where examiners expect students to reflect on trust, honesty, and the transformative power of kindness. In the 2024 board paper, one question asked, 'What values did Anil display in his treatment of Hari Singh?' — testing both textual understanding and the ability to articulate positive human qualities. CBSE also favors questions that link character traits to real-life lessons, encouraging students to connect literary study with moral education. When preparing, focus on character motivations (why Mrs Pumphrey pampered Tricki, why Hari returned the money, how Ausable stayed calm under threat), turning points in the narrative, and the broader themes each story explores. Practise framing answers with clear topic sentences, supporting evidence from the text, and brief concluding statements that tie back to the question. This approach aligns with CBSE marking schemes and maximizes your score.

Extract-based MCQs test close reading: speaker identification, irony, idiomatic expressions, factual details
2-3 mark questions ask 'Why' or 'How' about specific incidents or character decisions — answers need textual support
5-mark questions probe themes (trust, intelligence, satire), character evolution, or narrative technique
Value-based questions are common for 'The Thief's Story' — reflect on trust, honesty, second chances
Examiners reward answers that link character traits to real-life lessons or moral values
Use the PEEL structure: Point, Evidence (from text), Explanation, Link (to question)

Common Mistakes Students Make and How to Avoid Them

Many CBSE Class 10 students lose marks on Chapter 9 questions due to avoidable errors. A frequent mistake is confusing story details — for example, stating that Tricki underwent surgery when the entire point is that he did not, or claiming Hari was caught and punished when in fact Anil quietly forgave him. Always re-read the question carefully and check that your answer matches the story's actual events. Another common error is writing overly long answers for 2-mark questions; students waste time and risk losing expression marks by exceeding the word limit and including irrelevant detail. Stick to 40-50 words for 2-mark questions and 50-60 words for 3-mark questions. For MCQs, students often choose options based on partial memory rather than re-reading the extract provided; the correct answer is always supported by the extract text, so eliminate options that contradict it. In character-analysis questions, many students offer vague statements like 'Anil was a good person' without citing specific actions or dialogues — always ground character traits in textual evidence (e.g., 'Anil trusted Hari enough to let him handle money and offered to teach him reading and writing, showing kindness and patience'). A fourth mistake is neglecting to mention the moral or thematic lesson when the question explicitly asks for it; if a question says 'What values did Anil display?', list the values (trust, forgiveness, generosity) and link each to a story incident. Finally, students sometimes write answers in the first person ('I think Hari changed because...') instead of the objective third person required in board exams. Use formal, academic language and avoid personal opinions unless the question specifically invites reflection. Reviewing past board papers and practicing timed answers under exam conditions will help you internalize these guidelines and avoid common pitfalls.

Confusing story details (e.g., saying Tricki had surgery when he did not) — re-read the text before answering
Writing overly long answers for short questions — stick to word limits (40-50 for 2 marks, 50-60 for 3 marks)
Choosing MCQ options from memory rather than checking the extract — the correct answer is always text-supported
Offering vague character statements without textual evidence — cite specific actions or dialogues
Neglecting to mention values or themes when the question asks for them — link traits to incidents explicitly
Using first-person or informal language — maintain objective, formal tone throughout
Skipping introductory or concluding sentences in 5-mark answers — structure improves coherence and earns expression marks

Exam Preparation Strategy for Chapter 9 Supplementary Readings

To excel in questions from Chapter 9, start by reading each story at least twice — once for plot and character, and again for themes, irony, and narrative techniques. Make short notes on each character's key traits and turning points: for Tricki, note his transformation from listless to energetic; for Hari, his moment of moral awakening at the railway station; for Ausable, his calm fabrication of the balcony story. Underline or highlight important dialogues and descriptions that reveal character or theme, such as Anil's line 'He knew but he didn't mind' (showing forgiveness) or Ausable's confident assertion about the balcony. Practice writing answers within strict word limits using a timer — set two minutes for 2-mark questions, three minutes for 3-mark questions, and seven minutes for 5-mark questions. After writing, compare your answer with model answers from CBSE sample papers or guidebooks, checking for content accuracy, textual references, and language quality. Solve at least two previous years' board papers under timed conditions to familiarize yourself with question patterns and mark distribution. Focus on value-based questions by identifying the moral lesson in each story and practising how to articulate it clearly: A Triumph of Surgery teaches moderation and the dangers of overindulgence; The Thief's Story illustrates the power of trust and the possibility of redemption; The Midnight Visitor demonstrates that intelligence and composure can overcome physical threats. Finally, use digital resources like CBSETUTOR.ai, which offers 24×7 AI-powered doubt resolution for Class 10 English. You can upload a photo of any question from Chapter 9, and the AI tutor provides step-by-step explanations and model answers instantly. At a flat ₹999 per month for all subjects and classes (6-12), with a 3-day free trial, it is an affordable supplement to classroom learning, especially useful for last-minute revision and personalized practice. Consistent practice, textual familiarity, and strategic time management will ensure you score full marks on Chapter 9 questions in the 2025 board exam.

Read each story twice — once for plot, once for themes and narrative techniques
Make character-wise notes: key traits, turning points, important dialogues
Highlight textual evidence that reveals character or theme for quick reference during revision
Practice timed answers: 2 min for 2-mark, 3 min for 3-mark, 7 min for 5-mark questions
Compare your answers with CBSE sample papers and marking schemes to improve content and expression
Solve previous years' board papers to understand question patterns and mark distribution
Articulate the moral lesson clearly for value-based questions: moderation, trust, intelligence over brawn
Use CBSETUTOR.ai for instant AI-powered doubt resolution and model answers, available at ₹999/month with a 3-day free trial

Frequently asked questions

How many marks do the three stories in Chapter 9 carry in the CBSE Class 10 English board exam?+

Together, the three supplementary stories in Chapter 9 — A Triumph of Surgery, The Thief's Story, and The Midnight Visitor — typically carry 5-8 marks in the CBSE board exam, distributed across extract-based MCQs (1 mark), short-answer questions (2-3 marks), and occasionally a long-answer or case-based question (5 marks).

What is the main theme of 'A Triumph of Surgery' and how is it tested in exams?+

The main theme is the harm caused by excessive indulgence and the triumph of common sense over unnecessary medical intervention. CBSE questions often ask why the story is titled ironically, how Mr Herriot cured Tricki without surgery, or what values Mrs Pumphrey lacked. Answers must reference Tricki's overfeeding, lack of exercise, and recovery through discipline.

Why did Hari Singh return the stolen money in 'The Thief's Story'?+

Hari Singh returned the stolen six hundred rupees because he realized that Anil's trust, the opportunity to learn reading and writing, and the prospect of a respectable, literate life were far more valuable than short-term theft. This moral awakening occurred at the railway station and prompted him to return before dawn.

How did Ausable get rid of Max in 'The Midnight Visitor'?+

Ausable fabricated a convincing story about a balcony below the window, claiming intruders had used it before. When there was a knock at the door, Ausable said it was the police. Panicking, Max jumped out the window to the non-existent balcony and fell to his death. Ausable's calm intelligence outsmarted the armed intruder without any physical confrontation.

What kind of character questions are commonly asked from Chapter 9 in CBSE exams?+

Common character questions include: 'How did Anil's trust transform Hari Singh?', 'Describe Mrs Pumphrey's character and her treatment of Tricki', 'What was Fowler's impression of Ausable and how was it subverted?', and 'What values did Anil/Mr Herriot/Ausable display?' Answers require specific textual references and clear trait identification.

Are extract-based MCQs from these three stories difficult?+

No, extract-based MCQs are straightforward if you read the stories carefully. The correct answer is always supported by the extract provided. Focus on speaker identification, understanding irony or idioms, and recognizing plot details. Practice MCQs from CBSE sample papers to familiarize yourself with the format and eliminate wrong options systematically.

How should I structure a 3-mark answer on character transformation in 'The Thief's Story'?+

Start with a brief introductory statement identifying the transformation. Then present two or three specific points: Hari's initial plan to rob Anil, the moment of realization at the railway station, his decision to return the money, and Anil's quiet forgiveness. Support each point with a textual reference or quote. Conclude with the moral lesson (trust and education reform character). Aim for 50-60 words.

What are the most common mistakes students make when answering Chapter 9 questions?+

Common mistakes include confusing story details (e.g., claiming Tricki had surgery), exceeding word limits for short questions, choosing MCQ options from memory instead of the extract, offering vague character statements without textual evidence, neglecting to mention values or themes when asked, and using informal or first-person language instead of objective, formal tone.

Is there a moral or value-based lesson in 'A Triumph of Surgery'?+

Yes. The story teaches that excessive indulgence and pampering, even when driven by love, can harm those we care for. It also highlights the value of discipline, moderation, and common sense over unnecessary medical intervention. CBSE questions may ask what values Mrs Pumphrey lacked (discipline, restraint) or what Mr Herriot demonstrated (practical wisdom, compassion).

How can CBSETUTOR.ai help me prepare for Chapter 9 questions?+

CBSETUTOR.ai provides 24×7 AI-powered tutoring for CBSE Class 10 English. You can upload a photo of any Chapter 9 question and receive instant step-by-step model answers with textual references. It helps clarify doubts on character analysis, thematic understanding, and exam technique. Available at ₹999/month for all subjects (Classes 6-12) with a 3-day free trial, it is a cost-effective tool for personalized practice and last-minute revision.

Related resources

CBSE Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 9 A Triumph of Surgery / The Thief's Story / The Midnight Visitor Worksheet with Answers Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 9 A Triumph of Surgery / The Thief's Story / The Midnight Visitor — Formulas & Key Points CBSE Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 8 The Sermon at Benares / The Proposal Worksheet with Answers Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 8 The Sermon at Benares / The Proposal — Formulas & Key Points AI Tutor for Class 10: The Smart Alternative to Tuition AI Tutor for Class 10 Maths: Learn Faster with Instant Help Class 9 English — First Flight Chapter 1: A Letter to God, Dust of Snow & Fire and Ice — Previous Year Questions (2020–2025)Important Questions: CBSE Class 9 Mathematics Chapter 2 Polynomials

Keep learning — related guides

Class 10English — First Flight

Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 12 Writing Skills — Formulas & Key Points

Class 10English — First Flight

Important Questions: CBSE Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 12 Writing Skills

Class 10English — First Flight

Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 11 Grammar Toolkit — Formulas & Key Points

Class 10English — First Flight

CBSE Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 12 Writing Skills Worksheet with Answers

Class 10English — First Flight

Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 10 Footprints Without Feet / The Making of a Scientist / Bholi — Formulas & Key Points

Class 10English — First Flight

Important Questions: CBSE Class 10 English — First Flight Chapter 11 Grammar Toolkit

Ready to give your Class 10 child the tutor that never sleeps?

CBSETUTOR.ai covers every chapter in the Class 10 NCERT syllabus — Maths, Science, Social Science, English, Hindi and more. 24×7. Patient. Unlimited. 3-day free trial.

Start your child's 3-day free trial →